Reading a little Daniel Dennett here, I find he raises a good point. No matter which religious choice you make, MOST people disagree with you.
This is easily proven by looking at some simple statistics. A search for “largest religion in the world” quickly reveals that Christianity is the most adhered-to religion in the world. It ensnares roughly 2.1 billion people* in a world of roughly 7 billion. That’s right at 30%. I’d say that’s a close enough estimate to support my case, especially considering I’ve used the highest number I could find for Christian adherence.
Now, before continuing, let’s consider something else. That 2.1 billion includes ALL Christian denominations: Catholic, Protestant, Eastern Orthodox, Pentecostal, Anglican, Monophysite, African Initiated, Latter-day Saints, Evangelical, Seventh-Day Adventist, Jehovah’s Witnesses, Quakers, Assembly of God, and other nominal denominations. All in all, it’s reported there are over 38,000 different denominations.
So, even between the Christian faith, there is much division, and the percentage that agrees with you shrinks. Again, let’s go with the biggest faction: Roman Catholicism–claiming roughly 1.115 billion people as of 2007. We’re down to a generous 16%. Assuming we don’t dive any deeper into divisions and differences, we can rightfully deduce that AT LEAST 84% of the world is wrong about religion.
Why does this matter? What follows? Does this mean that those who are “educated” and know the right religion need to work harder at converting people? I think we all know MY answer to that. I think we need to step back at look at what this means for the religious.
I’m certainly not going to tell you that AT LEAST five out of six people disagree with you, NO MATTER WHAT YOU BELIEVE, so you should ditch your religion. That shouldn’t persuade you to change. Those same five out of six disagree with me, too.
But here’s the difference. You believe in a god who supposedly created and loves us and doesn’t WANT to send us to Hell, but will if he has to. The easiest way to be sent to Hell is to not believe in this god. At least five out of six people don’t believe in “it,” and are therefore going to Hell. My question is this: if “it” loves us so much, why are AT LEAST 84% of us going to Hell?
If we can imagine a school subject that god has to study and we call it “Making my own beloved creation believe I exist so they may share my kingdom with me for eternity as I intended when I created them because I love them so much because they are my creation/children,” I think it is safe to say that god fails miserably. I’ve never passed anything with 16%. If god is all-knowing and all-loving, he certainly doesn’t know how to show how much he loves his “children.” Better get on that, buddy.
*Wikipedia claims only 1.5 billion, giving a percentage closer to 21.4%
UPDATE: I realize this post is not a GREAT argument according to the rules of logic and would not prove or disprove anything scientifically. It is meant merely as a thought exercise as it began as a simple status update, and became much more as I hopped on this particular train of thought.